classics of misogynistic literature from Hesiod to the modern day
Below is a chronological sampler of widely discussed texts that contain sustained or strikingly negative generalizations about women, enforce female subordination, eroticize domination, or otherwise figure prominently in scholarly conversations about misogyny—from Hesiod through the contemporary era. Inclusion here doesn’t mean every line of a work is hostile to women, nor that the author “hated women” in a simple biographical sense. Many are complex, ironic, parodic, or voiced through characters; some have been forcefully reinterpreted by later readers. I flag them because they’ve become touchstones in debates about literary misogyny.
How I’m Using “Misogynistic”
Working definition: A text (or major passage) that (1) depicts women as inherently inferior, corrupting, dangerous, or burdensome as a class; (2) normalizes or eroticizes domination/violence toward women; (3) persistently trivializes women’s subjectivity; or (4) has attracted a durable critical tradition labeling it misogynistic. Context matters: sometimes a character speaks misogyny; sometimes satire undercuts it; sometimes readers disagree. I note such complications briefly.
Antiquity (Greek & Roman)
- Hesiod – Theogony & Works and Days (c. 700 BCE). The Pandora myth inaugurates “woman” as a divine punishment who unleashes woes on men; Works and Days amplifies economic/sexual anxieties about wives as consumers of male labor.
- Semonides of Amorgos – “Types of Women” (7th c. BCE). Iambic catalogue reducing women to animal-nature stereotypes (sow, fox, dog, etc.), ending that the best woman barely exists; a paradigmatic ancient misogynist poem.
- Euripides – Hippolytus (428 BCE; misogynist speeches). The title character’s tirades that “woman” is a plague are framed dramatically but have long been excerpted as antifeminist sententiae.
- Aristophanic Tradition (esp. Lysistrata, Thesmophoriazusae, Assemblywomen, 5th–4th c. BCE). Comic gender inversions rely on stock jokes about women’s lust, secrecy, and domestic foibles; reception divided between reading as satire on men vs. recycling misogynist tropes.
- Ovid – Ars Amatoria; parts of Amores & Metamorphoses (1 BCE–8 CE). Seduction “handbook” that encourages manipulative pursuit; the epic overflows with sexual coercion by gods and heroes—central to modern discussions of rape culture in classical myth.
- Juvenal – Satire VI (early 2nd c. CE). A blistering, book-length diatribe cataloguing every imaginable female vice; the canonical Roman invective against women.
- Martial – Selected Epigrams (1st c. CE). Recurrent mockery of wives, widows, and women’s bodies; brief but influential in shaping comic misogynist topoi.
Late Antiquity & Patristic / Early Christian Polemic
- Tertullian – De Cultu Feminarum (“On the Apparel of Women,” c. 2nd–3rd c.). Casts all women as “the devil’s gateway,” morally dangerous because of Eve’s precedent; foundational for later clerical antifeminism.
- Jerome – Adversus Jovinianum (c. 393 CE). In valorizing virginity, denigrates marriage and female sexuality; mined for antifeminist authorities in the Middle Ages.
Medieval Europe
- Andreas Capellanus – De Amore (late 12th c.). Book III overturns earlier courtly love rules with sweeping denunciations of women; its sincerity debated but long quoted as antifeminist proof text.
- Jean de Meun (continuation of Guillaume de Lorris) – Le Roman de la Rose (c. 1275). Allegorical encyclopedia that satirizes and slanders women’s morals, sexuality, & speech; the lightning rod that provoked Christine de Pizan’s famous defense of women.
- “Antifeminist Authorities” Compilations (e.g., Lamentations of Matheolus, florilegia). Sourcebooks of clerical slurs against wives—visible inside Chaucer’s Wife of Bath’s Prologue, which quotes and parodies them.
- Geoffrey Chaucer – Select Canterbury Tales Passages (late 14th c.). While Chaucer is often sympathetic, the Clerk’s Tale (extreme wifely obedience), Merchant’s Tale, and antifeminist citations in the Wife of Bath keep him central to the misogyny debate.
- Heinrich Kramer & Jacob Sprenger – Malleus Maleficarum (1486). Witch-hunting manual asserting women’s inherent carnality and susceptibility to the devil; massively influential in gendered persecution (polemical prose, yet culturally “classic”).
Reformation & Early Modern
- John Knox – The First Blast of the Trumpet Against the Monstrous Regiment of Women (1558). Polemic denying the legitimacy of female rulers (targeting Mary Tudor & Mary of Guise); seminal political misogyny.
- Joseph Swetnam – The Arraignment of Lewd, Idle, Froward, and Unconstant Women (1615). Popular pamphlet vilifying women; sparked a lively counter-pamphlet tradition (“Swetnam controversy”).
- William Shakespeare – The Taming of the Shrew (c. 1590–94). Comic “taming” of a rebellious woman; productions range from endorsing patriarchal submission to ironic critique—hence perpetual argument about misogyny.
- Ben Jonson – Epicoene, or The Silent Woman (1609). Satire of noise, marriage, and gender performance that trades in stereotypes of the desirable “silent” wife.
17th–18th Centuries (Restoration, Enlightenment, Augustan)
- Samuel Butler – Hudibras (1663–78, esp. anti-woman jibes). Burlesque poem including stock lampoons of female fickleness.
- Jonathan Swift – “The Lady’s Dressing Room” (1732); “A Beautiful Young Nymph Going to Bed” (1731). Scatological exposure poems deflating idealized femininity; often cited as classic literary disgust at women’s bodies.
- Alexander Pope – “Epistle II. To A Lady” (Moral Essays, 1735) & related verse. Brilliant couplets that reduce women to extremes (saint or devil, angel or ape); cornerstone of rhetorical misogyny discussions.
- Jean-Jacques Rousseau – Émile (1762, Book V on Sophie). Prescribes an education making women pleasing, modest, subordinate to men’s moral development; philosophically influential gender hierarchy.
19th Century & Turn of the 20th
- Arthur Schopenhauer – “On Women” (1851). Blanket claims of women’s intellectual & moral inferiority; heavily anthologized philosophical misogyny.
- Leo Tolstoy – The Kreutzer Sonata (1889). Narrator’s fevered condemnation of female sexuality & marriage; critics debate whether Tolstoy endorses or exposes pathological jealousy, but it’s long read as misogynist.
- August Strindberg – The Father (1887), Creditors (1888), Miss Julie (1888, contested). Ferocious gender battles; author’s public writings intensified charges of woman-hatred.
- Otto Weininger – Sex and Character (1903). Pseudo-scientific classification ranking “Woman” as amorphous, amoral; hugely influential in European intellectual circles.
20th Century (Modernist to Late)
- D. H. Lawrence – e.g., Women in Love (1920), Lady Chatterley’s Lover (1928). Erotic mysticism entwined with hierarchical gender myths; accused alternately of misogyny and of celebrating female desire—critical battleground.
- Ernest Hemingway – recurrent portrayals (e.g., The Sun Also Rises, 1926). Critics have read his women as projections of male anxiety; debates continue.
- Henry Miller – Tropic of Cancer (1934), Tropic of Capricorn (1939). Sexually explicit narratives objectifying women; landmark in censorship fights and misogyny critiques alike.
- Norman Mailer – An American Dream (1965); essay “The Prisoner of Sex” (1971). Violent fantasy & anti-feminist polemic made Mailer emblematic of postwar macho misogyny.
- Philip Roth – Portnoy’s Complaint (1969), later Sabbath’s Theater (1995). Male narrators whose obsessive sexual monologues slide into misogynist caricature; often defended as satire of their narrators.
- John Updike – Rabbit novels (1960–2000). Chronic domestic realism that, to some readers, reduces women to foils for male spiritual angst; frequently cited in feminist critique.
Late 20th–21st Century / Contemporary
- Bret Easton Ellis – American Psycho (1991). Graphic torture-murder of women amid consumer satire; debates over whether it indicts or reproduces misogynistic violence.
- Michel Houellebecq – Whatever (1994), The Elementary Particles (1998), Submission (2015), others. Bleak sexual-market novels voiced through alienated men whose contempt for women (and men) has drawn persistent charges of misogyny (often broadened to misanthropy).
- Neil Strauss – The Game (2005). Memoir/manual from pickup-artist culture that systematizes manipulative tactics toward women; culturally influential in contemporary misogynist subcultures (more pop-nonfiction than “literary classic,” but historically significant).
- Online “Manosphere” / Incel Forums Anthologies (2000s–present). Not canonical literature, yet vital primary sources for current misogynist rhetoric; if you’re mapping the tradition forward, these digital texts extend long-standing tropes into networked culture.
Pair Them with Counter-Voices
Reading misogynistic texts alongside feminist or woman-authored responses sharpens critical insight. Classic pairings include:
- Hesiod ↔ Sappho fragments (alternative female lyric voice).
- Roman de la Rose ↔ Christine de Pizan, The Book of the City of Ladies (1405).
- Swetnam ↔ Swetnam the Woman-Hater Arraigned by Women (1617).
- Knox ↔ Queen Elizabeth I’s speeches; Mary Astell’s A Serious Proposal to the Ladies.
- Pope/Swift ↔ Mary Wollstonecraft, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792).
- Schopenhauer/Weininger ↔ Simone de Beauvoir, The Second Sex (1949).
- Mailer/Roth/Ellis ↔ contemporary feminist criticism (e.g., Kate Millett’s Sexual Politics, 1970).
Using the List
Study suggestions:
- Contextualize: What social, theological, or political anxieties does the text displace onto “women”?
- Voice vs. Author: Distinguish character speech, narrator stance, and authorial irony.
- Reception History: Track when and why readers have labeled the work misogynistic; judgments change.
- Counter-Readings: What resistant or feminist readings reappropriate the text?
Want More?
If you’d like:
- Brief key passages to examine (with context & warnings),
- A syllabus-style reading sequence,
- Non-Western traditions (e.g., Confucian “admonitions to women,” certain legal-religious codes, or South Asian texts),
- Or a focus on literature that critiques misogyny rather than embodies it,
just let me know and I can expand or create a printable reading list.
No comments:
Post a Comment